Socialism in America

Americans are weary. We are weary of seeing billions of our hard-earned tax dollars going to fight forever wars. Weary of giving Israel a literal blank check as it commits genocide in Gaza, and carries out murderous pogroms in the West Bank. Weary of AIPAC’s tentacles wrapped around the necks of our elected leaders like a giant squid, turning so many of them into lapdogs who will do whatever Israel tells them. NYC Mayor Mamdani has referred to AIPAC as a monstrosity, which it is. And I don’t blame him for not marching in a pro-Israel parade. We must not reward genocide; Netanyahu has turned Israel into a terrorist state. (I’m Jewish, by the way, and am fiercely opposed to any form of antisemitism; it’s Netanyahu I despise.) We are weary of trillions lost to tax cuts for the super-rich and of being forced to pay for corporate welfare, as benefits are slashed for Americans who need help and who are going hungry and are deprived of medical care. Weary of watching helplessly while blood-sucking robber barons like venture capitalists and hedge-fund managers and Wall Street elites become fabulously wealthy at the expense of the American people who increasingly see their own futures as bleak and hopeless. The tech bros and other “masters of the universe” take everything, and shriek in protest as activists like Elizabeth Warren and Robert Reich call for them to pay their fair share of taxes. We are weary of infinite amounts of money for weapons while pleading poverty when the less privileged need our help. And we are weary of Trump claiming, falsely, that we won in Iran and that he’d conquered inflation and ushered in a fantastical “golden age” for the country.

For the first time in years I’m sensing signs of hope. Mamdani has initiated a revolution by doing what the entrenched powers-that-be see as their biggest threat: having the government give back to its citizens. It’s not complicated. For decades we have been browbeaten into believing we were helpless as we watched the rich get richer while ordinary citizens see their quality of life diminishing. It was just a matter of fact — power was for the rich, obscene amounts of money must be paid for corporate welfare, and the only ones getting breaks were those who need them least as they say to the rest of us, “Let them eat dirt.” He is actually giving back to his constituents, and he is enjoying a nearly seventy-percent approval rating. He has energized the entire nation. Young people everywhere are embracing democratic socialism, a model of government that is committed to the well being of its citizens.

I am not happy about the platform of the Democratic Socialists of America, but like all party platforms it’s pretty much meaningless. I don’t want to see defunding of the police, the abolition of ICE (though I think ICE needs to be razed to the ground and totally reformed), the complete opening of our borders, abolition of the Senate, no Thanksgiving and other pipe dreams. But Mamdani doesn’t stand for any of these things. He’s helping struggling New Yorkers with childcare, discounted supermarkets, a freeze on rents. And he is beloved. It seemed impossible; government was an arm of the wealthy and powerful and we average citizens would have to scramble for crumbs to keep our heads above water. Centrist Democrats like James Carville are hysterical, declaring the end of the Party. They don’t seem to realize there’s been a sea change, just as there was a few years ago when the majority of Americans finally approved of same-sex marriage. Many of us want the government overhauled so we can live with a robust safety net and universal healthcare. For years we were told such things were impossible, impractical, unattainable. But that is false. We have the resources. We just need leaders like Mamdani to unlock them. He has ushered in a new age of optimism. We’ll see if it’s sustainable but I’ve never seen such hopefulness before, similar to when Obama first won the presidency.

The depravity of the current administration cannot be exaggerated. I won’t list all their sins, like the pointless war in Iran, the desecration of the White House, the insanity with the reflecting pool, the outrageous corruption, Trump slapping his name on everything…Americans are tired of it. It’s reflected in all the recent polls; Trump has made our lives worse and the people are ready for dramatic change. It’s going to be a bitter battle as Trump seeks to suppress the vote and cling to power. But it can be done, and the exuberance of today’s young people can help usher in a new reality, one in which the government gives back to its citizens and frees itself from the blood-sucking super-rich. I am retired and live off of my investments. But I would gladly pay more in taxes to a government that actually cares about me and gives back in the form of universal healthcare and a lowering of the cost of living for everyday Americans. This coming election will determine whether we can transform our broken system with one that is of the people, by the people, and for the people. And I’m going to do all I can to usher in a better future. It’s time.

5
Comments

America through Chinese eyes

“I would never go to America. Everyone there has guns and I don’t want to get shot.” That’s what my young Chinese colleague said to me as we were working at the Beijing Olympics in 2008. To him, the US must be a dystopian hellscape to be avoided at all costs to protect life and limb. This was not the first time I heard Chinese people refer to America as being overrun by crime and lawlessness. Several friends of mine in China voiced similar, if less dramatic, opinions of America’s dangers.

It was very hard for me to argue about this. My friends and colleagues were hard-wired into seeing the US as crime infested and plagued with one mass shooting after another. I attribute this to indoctrination in Chinese schools and the media, seizing on any story of American violence as evidence of how dangerous life there is. Is it “brain washing”? I might not go that far, but it’s definitely something Chinese people learn about when they’re quite young.

Are they wrong? I’ve lived in America for decades, and never saw anyone get shot. But, unfortunately, we do have a real crime problem, and there are too many guns out there. And it’s true, one feels safer walking in Shanghai at night than they might in Chicago. In all my years in China, I never felt unsafe there. Crime in America is worse and more frequent. And brainwashing works both ways; Americans have been led to see China as a totalitarian dictatorship that arrests and persecutes those who raise their voice against tyranny. Just as with the perception of crime in the US, this view of China is not totally wrong; pro-democracy activists have been arrested, and uprisings have been violently quashed. But China has grown far more enlightened in recent years and the CCP is supported by most citizens. So the bottom line is that these perceptions of the US and China tell us there is indoctrination on both sides.

Along similar lines, I read an intriguing article a few weeks ago in the NY Times.

China increasingly casts itself not as a fading civilization trying to catch up to the West but as a superpower poised to surpass it. Chinese nationalists and state-linked commentators say they have Mr. Trump to thank. America under his rule, they say, validates Mr. Xi’s worldview centered on “the rise of the East and decline of the West.”

For decades, many Chinese viewed the United States with a mix of admiration, envy and resentment. America represented wealth, technological sophistication and institutional confidence. Even critics of Washington who reviled the American system often assumed that it worked….

Evidence of this shift is measurable: The use of terms related to “American decline” in official Chinese sources nearly doubled in 2025, according to a study by two Brookings Institution researchers.

The narrative of American decline did not begin with Mr. Trump. For years, Chinese state media and nationalist pundits have highlighted mass shootings, homelessness, political polarization and economic inequality in the United States as evidence of the failures of Western democracy. More recently, official outlets embraced the viral phrase “kill line,” borrowed from video game culture, to describe what they portrayed as the irreversible downward spiral facing America’s working poor. It’s a familiar tactic of the Communist Party to distract the Chinese public from the country’s own issues.

But Mr. Trump’s return to office and his administration’s erratic decision-making in both domestic and foreign policy have supplied the propaganda machine with plentiful fresh material. Images of immigration raids, the Minneapolis shootings and bitter political infighting circulate widely on Chinese social media alongside triumphant commentary about American dysfunction. What once sounded to many educated Chinese like exaggerated propaganda increasingly feels, to some, observational.

I must call out the success of China’s propagandists in painting the image of America as a civilization in decline. This is now status quo: the Chinese see America under Trump as sliding hopelessly backwards, though this conception had roots in China long before Trump came to power. I saw evidence of this 17 years ago when I worked for a Chinese newspaper, where I had countless conversations with the young, ambitious staff about life in the US versus China. I remember feeling frustrated that so many of them were convinced of America’s decay. And now, under Trump, it appears the Chinese are more convinced than ever that the US is a dangerous and lawless place. One of those interviewed in the NYT article

described watching footage of the Jan. 6, 2021, attack on the U.S. Capitol and finding himself thinking of the Red Guards that Mao Zedong dispatched to tear apart China’s institutions during the Cultural Revolution. That feeling returned more insistently with the immigration raids and the targeting of perceived enemies during Mr. Trump’s second term.

Are these perceptions wrong? I suppose it depends on whom you ask. For me, America right now is tragically wounded; Trump has turned us into a laughingstock and an international pariah. And yes, the MAGA insurrection surely evoked memories of the Cultural Revolution. So maybe it isn’t so hard to understand why the Chinese see us as engulfed in anarchy and self destruction. Trump’s invasion of Iran has exacerbated these perceptions a thousand-fold.

The war in Iran has reinforced the view that China has the upper hand with Mr. Trump. At a conference in late April, [Fudan University scholar] Mr. Wu argued that the war reduced Washington’s leverage against China while increasing Beijing’s by consuming American military and diplomatic attention in the Middle East.

This is not wrong. China is ascending as America gives up all the good will cultivated ever since the end of World War Two. I took a lot of criticism in 2008, when I remarked on this blog that this is “China’s century.” I stand by that conclusion more than ever as I watch us attack our allies and suck up to the likes of Kim Jong Un, Victor Orban and Vladimir Putin. And even when Trump is gone and saner voices are back in power, it will be incredibly difficult to win back that good will, to have our allies trust us again, to bring back institutions Trump has gutted, like the USAID. China has emerged as the global superpower who can get thing done. They will step in where America has retreated.

China is far from perfect (what an understatement). But they have outsmarted and out-maneuvered us. And I don’t know if this can be turned around in our lifetimes. Trump has another two years to wreak havoc on my country and I can only see things as getting worse, at least until we again have a Democratic Congress next year. But the damage has been done, and all we can do for now is sit back and watch while China fills the global leadership gap. As President Xi said recently, we have fallen into “the Thucydides trap,” and for now I see no way out.

Final thought: Trump’s war of choice against Iran makes it far easier for China to engage in a war of choice against Taiwan. How can we object? Trump has fucked us all.

3
Comments

A new chapter

PINNED

Several years ago I put up a post saying The Peking Duck was “officially closed.” I had had enough of blogging. Since then, I idiotically tried to breathe new life back into the blog with some new China-related posts but my heart just wasn’t in it. I don’t want to write about China anymore. I live half a world away and have nothing new to contribute to the conversation. So that part of my life is over. Meanwhile, I can’t bear to give up my site altogether. I long to write, to chronicle my life, to keep a log. That’s what I’m hoping to use the site for: to record memories and maybe comment on domestic issues. I may only put up a post every couple of months. I’m not going to put up five posts a day like I did twenty years ago.

Back in 2005 it was so exciting and it gave me a great sense of purpose. The likes of James Fallows and Andrew Sullivan and many other influencers were regular readers. But now that I’m twenty years older I don’t need the pressure. It was wonderful, building a community and holding “Peking duck dinners” in Beijing (more than forty people showed up at my last dinner party in 2009). But all good things must come to an end.

Check in now and then to see whether I put up anything new. As I said, I only plan to post rarely, and maybe it’s really more for me than for anyone else. Thanks for reading.

6
Comments