Mandatory AIDS testing for Yunnan workers

I’m not sure if this is good or bad.

China’s southwestern province of Yunnan will require annual AIDS tests for people working in hotels, nightclubs and other entertainment outlets, a local official and the government’s Xinhua News Agency said Tuesday. Under the new rules, announced Monday and effective immediately, those testing positive will be fired, Xinhua said, citing the text of the regulation.

But Wang Yinsheng, an official with the Yunnan AIDS Prevention Center, said health authorities wouldn’t insist that those found to be infected be fired. They could instead be moved to jobs not involving contact with the public, he suggested.

The free tests are meant to identify people with HIV and AIDS in order to provide them with treatment and curb the disease’s spread, said Wang.

“Identifying this special group of people helps to reduce the chance of spreading and helps them to get timely treatment,” Wang said.

Those who test positive for HIV/AIDS or for venereal diseases would be denied a certificate of good health, without which they cannot legally work in the hospitality or service industries, Xinhua said.

They make it sound as though this is an act of altruism. But I remember the horror stories about mandatory testing for hepatitis B and the misery that ensued for those unfortunate enough to be carriers. Will those who test positive be treated with magnanimity or stigmatization? China’s track record in protecting AIDS sufferers has been less than admirable (though it’s certainly getting better).

As I said, I’m not sure whether this is good or bad. I can understand taking extreme measures to stop the spread of a disease that runs rampant among sex workers. The other side of the coin is how these people will be treated after the test.

The Discussion: 3 Comments

News Flash: Mandatory AIDS testing for Yunnan workers

Mandatory AIDS testing for Yunnan workers
By Richard TPD

I’m not sure if this is good or bad. China’s southwestern province of
Yunnan will require annual AIDS tests for people working in hotels,
nightclubs and other entertainment outlets, a local off…

March 22, 2005 @ 6:40 pm | Comment

It seems completely counter-productive. After all, nobody catches AIDS from having an infected person carry your luggage or pour you a drink. Of course some of these “hotel, nightclub and entertainment personnel” may be providing extra services on top of that, but if so, they are probably already illegal workers anyway. And the first instincts of anybody who thinks their livelihood is at risk will be to bribe the testing officials.

March 23, 2005 @ 7:37 pm | Comment

Remember Gatica?

Think of all the fuss that hapened in America when somebody said that insurance companies might use read your DNA and refuse you cover.

This is genetic descrimination by another name and it is just as bad.

I thought that things were looking up when the scrapped mandatory heath screening before marriage, and then China does this.

March 24, 2005 @ 2:29 am | Comment

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.